The oft-quoted recommendation to make your dialogue as realistic as possible is sometimes the worst advice imaginable. The next time you’re in a conversation—or, even better, eavesdropping on someone else’s conversation—draw back a bit and evaluate what you’re hearing.
Those “ums,” “you knows,” and “so, likes…” that pepper our everyday speech may be realistic, but they don’t generally make for good dialogue on the page. Following are a list of unnecessary “fillers” to avoid in your fictional dialogue:
1. Tics and Time Buyers
“Like,” “you know, “um,” “uh,” “well,” “look,” “er,” “ah,” and their ilk rarely add anything to the conversation.
They’re little plugs our brains insert into the flow of our speech to give us time to piece together the right words and finish our thoughts.
In writing dialogue, only use these words when they indicate something about the character—and, even then, use them with extreme caution.
2. Reiterations
Whenever “huh?,” “what?,” “I didn’t hear you,” “I don’t understand,” or “could you repeat that?” crop in your dialogue and force characters to reiterate something they just said, it’s a sure indicator of one of two things:
1. The original line of dialogue was incomprehensible and needs to be rewritten.
2. The confused character’s question and the subsequent explanation are unnecessary and should be deleted.
3. Repetitions
Don’t let your characters get away with echoing each other:
“I burnt the dinner.”
“You burnt the dinner. How’d that happen?”
“I don’t know how it happened. It just did.”
Keep each line of dialogue fresh and punchy with new material:
“I burnt the dinner.”
“How’d that happen?”
“It just did.”
4. Info Dumps
In real life, you’d get strange looks and lose friends if you went around saying things like the following:
“As you know, Bob, our sister got married last Tuesday and we both missed her wedding because we discussed it amongst ourselves and decided together that we wanted to spite her.”
Unless there’s a good reason for including such information in dialogue, spare your characters and your readers and place the necessary info into the narrative instead.
5. Small Talk
Introductions, greetings, farewells, chitchat about the weather—nine times out of ten all that good stuff completely unnecessary to the plot and adds little or nothing to character development. Ax it relentlessly.
6. Direct Address
Characters calling each other by name is one of the subtler forms of “filling,” but, ironically, it’s also one of the most unrealistic attempts to create authentic dialogue. In real life, we generally call people by name only when trying to get their attention, when emphasizing a point, when in the throes of strong emotion, or to avoid confusion.
***
Dialogue is one of the most fun bits of fiction to write, in large part because the gloves are off and “the rules” rarely apply. In fact, none of these “rules” I’ve listed here will apply in every circumstance. Sometimes you’ll make the educated choice to use one or all of these fillers to advance your plot or illustrate something about a character. Just make certain you understand why and when to use them. Now, sit back and let ’em talk!
#4 is my absolute biggest pet peeve in dialogue!!! EEERRRGGGHHHH!!!!!
Getting ticked off by it is the first step to not repeating it in our own writing. 🙂
These are all great, there is also the repetitive nature of much conversation with people saying the same thing several different ways. There is also the temptation to have your characters dissect the subject covering every possible outcome, like students at a bar after a couple too many beers.
Yes, makes you think we humans aren’t so very good at conversation after all. 😉
#1 The occasional “um” and such are dropped mainly by one character in my SFF WIP. He’s meant to be a little dorky, and being from a different time period than the rest of the cast, he doesn’t know what he’s doing sometimes. It actually helps show this side of his character, I think.
It’s all about context, right? 🙂
Great advice for writing realistic dialogue. Numbers 4 and 6 are my pet peeves. I see those more often than I would like to in my reading.